RA2 PAPER: Shifting paradigms in indigenous ...

Shifting paradigms and creating space for Indigenous leadership in biosecurity management and decision-making

November 2024

Godfery T, Keen J, Hikuroa D, Robinson A, Williams N. 2024. Shifting paradigms and creating space for Indigenous leadership in biosecurity management and decision-making. Conservation Biology 38(6) 11p.

ABSTRACT

In New Zealand, awareness regarding protection, enhancement, and regeneration of land-scapes and biodiversity is growing as the relationship between functioning and diverse ecosystems and society’s health is acknowledged. This relationship is especially important for Indigenous people, who hold strong genealogical and familial ties with nature. Significant biodiversity loss from anthropogenic factors is exacerbated by climate change, ecosystem degradation, and invasive species. Invasive species and other biological threats,such as native pathogens, are concerning for Māori communities, who hold cultural responsibilities to care for nature. Despite acknowledgment of the value of Indigenous perspectives in environmental management in New Zealand and globally, Indigenous participation still largely occurs within Western non-Indigenous paradigms. We highlight the value of Indigenous participation in biosecurity management and propose a shift from Western-based paradigms to paradigms that reflect Indigenous worldviews and relationships with place. Recognizing and including the value of Indigenous participation elevates Indigenous voices to the level of decision-making and leadership in the management of Indigenous lands. Given the genealogical relationships that Māori hold with the natural world and the intertwining of their health and well-being with that of place (land) and nature, biosecurity threats to native species and ecosystems also pose serious risks to community well-being. A holistic biosecurity approach is needed that encompasses cultural,social, economic, and environmental factors at multiple scales. We examined the New Zealand biosecurity context relative to biological threats to native plants and ecosystems and proposed a paradigm shift toward Indigenous place-based biosecurity management. Biosecurity science and science-based tools remain an important component, underscoring the complementary aspects of science and (Indigenous) culture.

KEYWORDS

biosecurity management; contrasting worldviews; Indigenous paradigms; nature relationships